The narrative continues without a break. Saul, having promised attractive rewards to the slayer of Goliath (
ch. 17:25), now called for David and inquired as to his identity. If we insert
ch. 16:14-23 between vs. ch.
9 and 10 of 18, as some scholars do, Saul’s first contact with David would thus be at the battle front, and the reason for Saul’s mental disturbance would lie in the adulation David received from the populace (
vs. 7>6, 7). If, however, the account is in chronological order, Saul’s question (
ch. 17:55) might be explained by supposing that Saul had taken so little notice of the humble lyre player during his spells of abstraction that he did not know who David was, in which case
ch. 16:21 would be regarded as mentioning later developments. The latter seems preferable (see on
ch. 16:21). In either case, since David was both a military hero and an inspired musician, it would be small wonder that Saul
“let him go no more home to his father’s house” (
ch. 18:2). See also on
ch. 17:15.